UK MP says BNPL corporations are “subsequent Wonga ready to occur” – FinTech Futures


Greater than 70 cross-party MPs within the UK have known as for purchase now, pay later (BNPL) corporations within the UK to satisfy stricter regulation.

The group of parliamentary representatives tabled an modification to the monetary providers invoice on Wednesday. They wish to push by means of laws inside three months of the invoice passing.

Simply 22% of the nation didn’t carry private debt into 2021

Labour MP Stella Creasy, who led the digital name with different MPs reported on by The Guardian, mentioned the likes of Klarna, Laybuy, and Clearpay are “the subsequent Wonga ready to occur”.

Payday lender Wonga collapsed in August 2018. Publish-crash, 1000’s of shoppers had been nonetheless making an attempt to recuperate claims for compensation because of mis-sold loans.

However the Monetary Ombudsman stopped investigating these claims when it turned clear Wonga wouldn’t have the ability to pay up.

The autumn of Wonga has seen a speedy decline within the variety of payday lenders ever since on the UK excessive road. The likes of The Cash Store, QuickQuid, H&T, PiggyBank, My Money Partner and Swift Sterling have all since disappeared.

Are BNPLs the brand new Wonga?

Creasy says “the lesson from Wonga is the longer we take to behave, the extra folks get into unaffordable debt”.

In response to a examine by, simply 22% of the nation didn’t carry private debt into 2021. The typical British grownup ended 2020 with £9,246 value of complete debt.

“It’s not by chance that these [BNPL] corporations generate profits from folks sending greater than they will afford,” Creasy mentioned.

“Many individuals have [financially] overcommitted themselves utilizing BNPL corporations, and we face mass redundancies, furloughing, and drops in revenue,” Creasy provides. “So even in the event you suppose you can afford it now, you won’t have the ability to later.”

UK BNPL suppliers, which embody Klarna, Laybuy, Clearpay and UK newcomers to the service PayPal and Zilch, all provide variations on an instalment-based funds plan. The time intervals for reimbursement, product worth limits and curiosity charges all differ.

Not like payday lenders, BNPL corporations put nearly all of threat onto the patron, who picks up the late charges, curiosity and potential hits to their credit score rating.

Klarna’s annual share charge (APR) within the UK is eighteen.9%, nonetheless few share factors decrease than a typical bank card.

Barclaycard, one of many UK’s largest bank card suppliers, reported a 7.1% drop in card revenues final yr. However Melbourne-born BNPL agency Afterpay, the guardian of UK arm Clearpay, noticed its worth rise 922% to a $18.7 billion market capitalisation in simply eight months final yr.


One of many main parallels between BNPL fintechs and payday lenders is the amount of complaints. Simply as complaints and calls for for compensation lastly crippled the likes of Wonga, MPs fear BNPL corporations might fall into the identical destiny.

Resolver acquired 4,962 complaints about BNPL credit score suppliers between April and September 2020. That’s up 22% on the earlier six months.

On Trustpilot, a standard criticism is corporations proceed to withdraw funds even when an merchandise is defective or refunded. Different prospects declare to have solely acquired partial refunds – some as little as 25% of the unique buy.

For Klarna, complaints have culminated within the start of the “KlarNAA” marketing campaign. It critiques the fintech for drawing younger customers into debt-fuelled spending with out making the dangers clear.

A Examine the Market survey final yr discovered that greater than 40% of BNPL customers had been unaware missed funds might have an effect on their credit score scores.

What regulators have achieved to this point

In September 2020, the Monetary Conduct Authority launched the Woolard Review to analyze unregulated credit score suppliers like Klarna.

The outcomes, set to land someday in 2021, received’t have an effect on interest-free merchandise which nearly all of gamers now provide. That’s as a result of they don’t come below the patron credit score umbrella.

However while they don’t class as client credit score, interest-free cost plans nonetheless incur charges for late funds and nonetheless run the chance of permitting shoppers to spend greater than they’ve.

Klarna is at the moment the topic of two separate UK regulatory probes. The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) is investigating claims that Klarna despatched its e-newsletter to individuals who had by no means used its providers.

The fintech can also be below investigation from Promoting Requirements Authority (ASA). This is because of claims its advertising drives younger folks into debt with out making them conscious of the dangers concerned.

Learn subsequent: London BNPL fintech Zilch latest to enter UK market with $30m